//
you're reading...
Cases, Yong Vui Kong

The Mule, the Mastermind and the MDP

At a Parliamentary sitting on 15 September 2010, then-NCMP Sylvia Lim posed an interesting question to then-Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Home Affairs, Wong Kan Seng. She asked if the government had detained, under the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act, any person believed to have organised drug trafficking activities involving Yong Vui Kong, an inmate on death Row.

The Minister’s response was just as interesting. In a written reply, Wong said, “Apart from Yong, there were indeed others who were part of the syndicate. Several have been prosecuted for trafficking. One has been detained under the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act.” (Read Wong’s full statement here.)

In a recent letter to Yong’s lawyer, M Ravi, the Attorney General’s Chambers (AGC) identified that person as Chia Choon Leng – the very same person Yong had named, in a police statement, as the mastermind of his crime. However the AGC said Yong also made it clear that he did not wish to identify Chia in court. (Read AGC’s letter and M Ravi’s query here.)

The AGC said Prosecution did not call Chia as a witness because his evidence was not necessary for their case. It said it also informed the Defense about the detention, however, Yong’s then-lawyers decided not to call Chia as a witness. According to court records, the Prosecution withdrew charges against Chia due to “the difficulty of the evidence”. Instead, “executive action” was taken against him.

It is unclear why Yong decided not to identify Chia in court. One can only speculate. What is clear though is that despite “the difficulty of the evidence”, Chia remains in custody. This must surely mean that authorities have sufficient reason to detain him. But while Chia will eventually be let go, Yong has been sentenced to hang.

Therein lies the problem with the Mandatory Death Penalty. Our judges’ hands are tied. Once a person is found guilty of trafficking in a certain amount of drugs, the court has no choice but to send him to the gallows. The government has regularly argued that draconian measures are necessary in order to keep Singapore drug-free. However, we can see from Yong’s case that bigger fish are sometimes allowed to get away, not only without conviction, but without charge.

If Singapore wants to be serious about crime prevention, it needs to rethink its strategy. State-sanctioned killing isn’t the answer. It leaves open the possibility that innocent people might be sentenced to death, and in the case of the MDP, it creates outcomes that are manifestly unfair. Very often, drug mules are themselves victims of their circumstances – they tend to be young, vulnerable and ignorant. Chia should be thoroughly investigated and charged, not held without trial. Yong, for his part, should be punished. Drug trafficking is, after all, a serious offense. But he does not deserve to die.

Advertisements

About Kirsten

A multi-purpose spud constantly searching for stories, and ways to tell them.

Discussion

5 thoughts on “The Mule, the Mastermind and the MDP

  1. If Yong is executed then the govt would be guilty of being one of the STUPIDEST administration in the world in the fight against illicit drug trafficking for it would have put to death a person who would be able to collaborate in striking a body blow against at least one of the big boys of the illicit drug trade. One hopes that that is among the reasons for the stay of execution and such a supremely tragic irony would NEVER come to pass. It would be a monstrous miscarriage of justice which IMO the govt would never be able to live down.

    Why would YVK not take the stand against Chia? Could it be there is NO provision in the law for him to use it to bargain for his own life?

    Back to Chia, it seems unbelievable that given the huge resources at its disposal, the govt and the SPF and the CNB are unable to pin down the nec. evidence to charge those ‘few others’? Incredible! Or, is it incredible INCOMPETENCE that is the problem? A very senior SPF official is in fact at this moment serving as the boss of Interpol. Seen in this light the govt’s lack of success is truly mind-boggling.

    The possible reasons for such ineptness is extremely troubling. Is it too far fetched to speculate that it has got something to do with the open secret about our govt’s pally dealing with the Burmese drug lords?

    Posted by george | November 13, 2011, 8:39 pm
  2. Is now December. What happens do Yong Vul Kong case now?
    Has the appointment of new president Tony Tan made a fresh clemency any help at all?

    Posted by Simon | December 5, 2011, 7:29 pm

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Pingback: Happy 24th Birthday, Vui Kong | Lianain Films - January 20, 2012

  2. Pingback: Happy 24th Birthday, Vui Kong | Lianain Films - January 21, 2012

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: